The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has frozen the assets of Backward Hat Capital and its co-founders, Phillip Williams and Devin Johnson, alleging they operated a $560 million Ponzi scheme. The firm reportedly promised investors high returns from AI-driven currency trading after converting their funds into crypto assets.

Key takeaways

  • The SEC, CFTC, and federal prosecutors have taken parallel actions against Backward Hat Capital and its co-founders.
  • The scheme allegedly raised over $560 million from more than 2,000 investors since July 2022.
  • Funds were purportedly converted to crypto, but little was used for foreign exchange trading; instead, money went to personal accounts and earlier investors.
  • Defendants are accused of creating fake financial reports to deceive investors about the scheme's legitimacy.
  • This case is part of a series of recent enforcement actions by regulators against crypto-related fraud.

Regulators Act Against Alleged $560 Million Ponzi

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has frozen the assets of Indianapolis-based Backward Hat Capital and its co-founders, Phillip Williams and Devin Johnson. The agency alleges the firm ran a $560 million Ponzi scheme, telling investors their money would be converted into crypto and used for AI-driven currency trading. The scheme reportedly raised funds from over 2,000 investors starting in July 2022.

A federal court granted a temporary restraining order, an asset freeze, and expedited discovery to halt the alleged ongoing scheme. Federal prosecutors in New York and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) have also brought parallel cases. The SEC and CFTC suits were filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, with the court appointing Kevin B. Duff as temporary receiver to take control of the companies and individual defendants’ assets, according to the CFTC.

The Promise of Crypto, AI, and High Returns

According to the SEC’s complaint, Williams and Johnson sold limited partnership interests in private funds, including to Williams’s former investment advisory clients. They promised a proprietary, “AI-driven” algorithm that supposedly generated at least 6% monthly returns by trading foreign exchange (FX). The pitch claimed investor money would first be converted into a crypto asset and then used for arbitrage, though the complaint does not specify bitcoin as the asset.

Approximately $109 million of the roughly $210 million raised from July 2022 to September 2025 was reportedly sent to the fund’s Coinbase account and converted. However, more than $56 million of that amount went to personal crypto accounts held by Williams, Johnson, and a relief defendant. About $40 million ended up on three platforms where some of it was used to trade other crypto assets, but little to no money was used for FX trading. After October 2025, the scheme raised about $350 million, none of which was sent to Coinbase.

Misappropriation of Funds and Deceptive Practices

The SEC stated that the defendants made over $250 million in Ponzi payments to earlier investors and moved more than $220 million to themselves. These funds allegedly financed exotic cars, expensive homes, private air travel, and other businesses they owned, and also supported Johnson’s gambling. Promoters involved in the scheme reportedly received more than $50 million.

Joseph Anderson is accused of producing fake financial reports, including at least two “audit reports” and a “quality of earnings” report from a supposedly independent firm. The SEC said these documents falsely claimed that returns had been verified against bank and brokerage records. The agency clarified that Anderson performed no actual audit work, was not independent, and had a financial stake in the scheme.

Prosecutors in Manhattan charged Williams and Johnson with securities fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit securities fraud. The FBI arrested Williams in Kokomo, Indiana, and Johnson in Gilbert, Arizona, on Wednesday. Prosecutors estimate the total amount raised by the scheme to be over $600 million.

U.S. Attorney Jamie McDonald stated, “As alleged, Phillip Patrick Williams and Devin Allen Johnson promised to use investor funds for profitable foreign exchange currency trading. Williams and Johnson instead stole hundreds of millions of dollars from their investors for personal expenses and to pay off earlier investors in a Ponzi-like fashion.” The CFTC estimates the Ponzi scheme involved over $550 million from at least 2,100 participants, with defendants soliciting money through at least October 2026. Both the CFTC and SEC are seeking injunctions, disgorgement of ill-gotten gains, and civil penalties.

What This Means for Holders

This case serves as a critical reminder for investors to exercise extreme caution and conduct thorough due diligence before committing funds to any investment opportunity, particularly those promising unusually high returns. The involvement of crypto assets in the scheme, even if not bitcoin specifically, highlights how bad actors can leverage the perceived novelty of digital assets to attract unsuspecting investors.

The coordinated actions by the SEC, CFTC, and federal prosecutors demonstrate a continued regulatory focus on combating fraud in the digital asset space. This aligns with broader efforts to establish clear regulatory frameworks, as discussed in our SEC Reg Crypto Framework: What Every Crypto Investor Needs to Know article. Investors should be wary of pitches that combine buzzwords like “AI-driven” and “crypto” with guaranteed high monthly returns, as these are common characteristics of fraudulent schemes. As Anne McKinley, acting associate director of the SEC’s Chicago Regional Office, noted, the promise of “a low-risk, high rate of return on a purportedly complex investment should make all potential investors stop and think before investing their money.”

Sources